Steady-state and time-resolved fluorescent methodologies to characterize the conformational landscape of the selectivity filter of K+ channels.

A variety of equilibrium and non-equilibrium methods have been used in a multidisciplinary approach to study the conformational landscape associated with the binding of different cations to the pore of potassium channels. These binding processes, and the conformational changes resulting therefrom, modulate the functional properties of such integral membrane properties, revealing these permeant and blocking cations as true effectors of such integral membrane proteins. KcsA, a prototypic K+ channel from Streptomyces lividans, has been extensively characterized in this regard. Here, we revise several fluorescence-based approaches to monitor cation binding under different experimental conditions in diluted samples, analyzing the advantages and disadvantages of each approach. These studies have contributed to explain the selectivity, conduction, and inactivation properties of K+ channels at the molecular level, together with the allosteric communication between the two gates that control the ion channel flux, and how they are modulated by lipids.

Anionic Phospholipids Shift the Conformational Equilibrium of the Selectivity Filter in the KcsA Channel to the Conductive Conformation: Predicted Consequences on Inactivation.

Here, we report an allosteric effect of an anionic phospholipid on a model K+ channel, KcsA. The anionic lipid in mixed detergent-lipid micelles specifically induces a change in the conformational equilibrium of the channel selectivity filter (SF) only when the channel inner gate is in the open state. Such change consists of increasing the affinity of the channel for K+, stabilizing a conductive-like form by maintaining a high ion occupancy in the SF. The process is highly specific in several aspects: First, lipid modifies the binding of K+, but not that of Na+, which remains unperturbed, ruling out a merely electrostatic phenomenon of cation attraction. Second, no lipid effects are observed when a zwitterionic lipid, instead of an anionic one, is present in the micelles. Lastly, the effects of the anionic lipid are only observed at pH 4.0, when the inner gate of KcsA is open. Moreover, the effect of the anionic lipid on K+ binding to the open channel closely emulates the K+ binding behaviour of the non-inactivating E71A and R64A mutant proteins. This suggests that the observed increase in K+ affinity caused by the bound anionic lipid should result in protecting the channel against inactivation.

Modulation of the potassium channel KcsA by anionic phospholipids: Role of arginines at the non-annular lipid binding sites.

The role of arginines R64 and R89 at non-annular lipid binding sites of KcsA, on the modulation of channel activity by anionic lipids has been investigated. In wild-type (WT) KcsA reconstituted into asolectin lipid membranes, addition of phosphatidic acid (PA) drastically reduces inactivation in macroscopic current recordings. Consistent to this, PA increases current amplitude, mean open time and open probability at the single channel level. Moreover, kinetic analysis reveals that addition of PA causes longer open channel lifetimes and decreased closing rate constants. Effects akin to those of PA on WT-KcsA are observed when R64 and/or R89 are mutated to alanine, regardless of the added anionic lipids. We interpret these results as a consequence of interactions between the arginines and the anionic PA bound to the non-annular sites. NMR data shows indeed that at least R64 is involved in binding PA. Moreover, molecular dynamics (MD) simulations predict that R64, R89 and surrounding residues such as T61, mediate persistent binding of PA to the non-annular sites. Channel inactivation depends on interactions within the inactivation triad (E71-D80-W67) behind the selectivity filter. Therefore, it is expected that such interactions are affected when PA binds the arginines at the non-annular sites. In support of this, MD simulations reveal that PA binding prevents interaction between R89 and D80, which seems critical to the effectiveness of the inactivation triad. This mechanism depends on the stability of the bound lipid, favoring anionic headgroups such as that of PA, which thrive on the positive charge of the arginines.

Conformational plasticity in the KcsA potassium channel pore helix revealed by homo-FRET studies.

Potassium channels selectivity filter (SF) conformation is modulated by several factors, including ion-protein and protein-protein interactions. Here, we investigate the SF dynamics of a single Trp mutant of the potassium channel KcsA (W67) using polarized time-resolved fluorescence measurements. For the first time, an analytical framework is reported to analyze the homo-Förster resonance energy transfer (homo-FRET) within a symmetric tetrameric protein with a square geometry. We found that in the closed state (pH 7), the W67-W67 intersubunit distances become shorter as the average ion occupancy of the SF increases according to cation type and concentration. The hypothesis that the inactivated SF at pH 4 is structurally similar to its collapsed state, detected at low K+, pH 7, was ruled out, emphasizing the critical role played by the S2 binding site in the inactivation process of KcsA. This homo-FRET approach provides complementary information to X-ray crystallography in which the protein conformational dynamics is usually compromised.

Selective exclusion and selective binding both contribute to ion selectivity in KcsA, a model potassium channel.

The selectivity filter in potassium channels, a main component of the ion permeation pathway, configures a stack of binding sites (sites S1-S4) to which K+ and other cations may bind. Specific ion binding to such sites induces changes in the filter conformation, which play a key role in defining both selectivity and permeation. Here, using the potassium channel KcsA as a model, we contribute new evidence to reinforce this assertion. First, ion binding to KcsA blocked by tetrabutylammonium at the most cytoplasmic site in the selectivity filter (S4) suggests that such a site, when in the nonconductive filter conformation, has a higher affinity for cation binding than the most extracellular S1 site. This filter asymmetry, along with differences in intracellular and extracellular concentrations of K+versus Na+ under physiological conditions, should strengthen selection of the permeant K+ by the channel. Second, we used different K+ concentrations to shift the equilibrium between nonconductive and conductive states of the selectivity filter in which to test competitive binding of Na+ These experiments disclosed a marked decrease in the affinity of Na+ to bind the channel when the conformational equilibrium shifts toward the conductive state. This finding suggested that in addition to the selective binding of K+ and other permeant species over Na+, there is a selective exclusion of nonpermeant species from binding the channel filter, once it reaches a fully conductive conformation. We conclude that selective binding and selective exclusion of permeant and nonpermeant cations, respectively, are important determinants of ion channel selectivity.

Towards understanding the molecular basis of ion channel modulation by lipids: Mechanistic models and current paradigms.

Research on ion channel modulation has become a hot topic because of the key roles these membrane proteins play in both prokaryotic and eukaryotic organisms. In this respect, lipid modulation adds to the overall modulatory mechanisms as a potential via to find new pharmacological targets for drug design based on interfering with lipid/channel interactions. However, our knowledge in this field is scarce and often circumscribed to the sites where lipids bind and/or its final functional consequences. To fully understand this process it is necessary to improve our knowledge on its molecular basis, from the binding sites to the signalling pathways that derive in structural and functional effects on the ion channel. In this review, we have compiled information about such mechanisms and established a classification into four different modes of action. Afterwards, we have revised in more detail the lipid modulation of Cys-loop receptors and of the potassium channel KcsA, which were chosen as model channels modulated by specific lipids. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Membrane Lipid Therapy: Drugs Targeting Biomembranes edited by Pablo V. Escribá.

Differential binding of monovalent cations to KcsA: Deciphering the mechanisms of potassium channel selectivity.

This work explores whether the ion selectivity and permeation properties of a model potassium channel, KcsA, could be explained based on ion binding features. Non-permeant Na+ or Li+ bind with low affinity (millimolar KD's) to a single set of sites contributed by the S1 and S4 sites seen at the selectivity filter in the KcsA crystal structure. Conversely, permeant K+, Rb+, Tl+ and even Cs+ bind to two different sets of sites as their concentration increases, consistent with crystallographic evidence on the ability of permeant species to induce concentration-dependent transitions between conformational states (non-conductive and conductive) of the channel's selectivity filter. The first set of such sites, assigned also to the crystallographic S1 and S4 sites, shows similarly high affinities for all permeant species (micromolar KD's), thus, securing displacement of potentially competing non-permeant cations. The second set of sites, available only to permeant cations upon the transition to the conductive filter conformation, shows low affinity (millimolar KD's), thus, favoring cation dissociation and permeation and results from the contribution of all S1 through S4 crystallographic sites. The differences in affinities between permeant and non-permeant cations and the similarities in binding behavior within each of these two groups, correlate fully with their permeabilities relative to K+, suggesting that binding is an important determinant of the channel's ion selectivity. Conversely, the complexity observed in permeation features cannot be explained just in terms of binding and likely relates to reported differences in the occupancy of the S2 and S3 sites by the permeant cations.

Competing Lipid-Protein and Protein-Protein Interactions Determine Clustering and Gating Patterns in the Potassium Channel from Streptomyces lividans (KcsA).

There is increasing evidence to support the notion that membrane proteins, instead of being isolated components floating in a fluid lipid environment, can be assembled into supramolecular complexes that take part in a variety of cooperative cellular functions. The interplay between lipid-protein and protein-protein interactions is expected to be a determinant factor in the assembly and dynamics of such membrane complexes. Here we report on a role of anionic phospholipids in determining the extent of clustering of KcsA, a model potassium channel. Assembly/disassembly of channel clusters occurs, at least partly, as a consequence of competing lipid-protein and protein-protein interactions at nonannular lipid binding sites on the channel surface and brings about profound changes in the gating properties of the channel. Our results suggest that these latter effects of anionic lipids are mediated via the Trp(67)-Glu(71)-Asp(80) inactivation triad within the channel structure and its bearing on the selectivity filter.

Experimental resistance to drug combinations in Leishmania donovani: metabolic and phenotypic adaptations.

Together with vector control, chemotherapy is an essential tool for the control of visceral leishmaniasis (VL), but its efficacy is jeopardized by growing resistance and treatment failure against first-line drugs. To delay the emergence of resistance, the use of drug combinations of existing antileishmanial agents has been tested systematically in clinical trials for the treatment of visceral leishmaniasis (VL). In vitro, Leishmania donovani promastigotes are able to develop experimental resistance to several combinations of different antileishmanial drugs after 10 weeks of drug pressure. Using an untargeted liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS) metabolomics approach, we identified metabolic changes in lines that were experimentally resistant to drug combinations and their respective single-resistant lines. This highlighted both collective metabolic changes (found in all combination therapy-resistant [CTR] lines) and specific ones (found in certain CTR lines). We demonstrated that single-resistant and CTR parasite cell lines show distinct metabolic adaptations, which all converge on the same defensive mechanisms that were experimentally validated: protection against drug-induced and external oxidative stress and changes in membrane fluidity. The membrane fluidity changes were accompanied by changes in drug uptake only in the lines that were resistant against drug combinations with antimonials, and surprisingly, drug accumulation was higher in these lines. Together, these results highlight the importance and the central role of protection against oxidative stress in the different resistant lines. Ultimately, these phenotypic changes might interfere with the mode of action of all drugs that are currently used for the treatment of VL and should be taken into account in drug development.

Detergent-labile, supramolecular assemblies of KcsA: relative abundance and interactions involved.

In this work, we illustrate the ability of the prokaryotic potassium channel KcsA to assemble into a variety of supramolecular clusters of defined sizes containing the tetrameric KcsA as the repeating unit. Such clusters, particularly the larger ones, are markedly detergent-labile and thus, disassemble readily upon exposure to the detergents commonly used in protein purification or conventional electrophoresis analysis. This is a reversible process, as cluster re-assembly occurs upon detergent removal and without the need of added membrane lipids. Interestingly, the dimeric ensemble between two tetrameric KcsA molecules are quite resistant to detergent disassembly to individual KcsA tetramers and along with the latter, are likely the basic building blocks through which the larger clusters are organized. As to the proteins domains involved in clustering, we have observed disassembly of KcsA clusters by SDS-like alkyl sulfates. As these amphiphiles bind to inter-subunit, "non-annular" sites on the protein, these observations suggest that such sites also mediate channel-channel interactions leading to cluster assembly.

N-type inactivation of the potassium channel KcsA by the Shaker B "ball" peptide: mapping the inactivating peptide-binding epitope.

The effects of the inactivating peptide from the eukaryotic Shaker BK(+) channel (the ShB peptide) on the prokaryotic KcsA channel have been studied using patch clamp methods. The data show that the peptide induces rapid, N-type inactivation in KcsA through a process that includes functional uncoupling of channel gating. We have also employed saturation transfer difference (STD) NMR methods to map the molecular interactions between the inactivating peptide and its channel target. The results indicate that binding of the ShB peptide to KcsA involves the ortho and meta protons of Tyr(8), which exhibit the strongest STD effects; the C4H in the imidazole ring of His(16); the methyl protons of Val(4), Leu(7), and Leu(10) and the side chain amine protons of one, if not both, the Lys(18) and Lys(19) residues. When a noninactivating ShB-L7E mutant is used in the studies, binding to KcsA is still observed but involves different amino acids. Thus, the strongest STD effects are now seen on the methyl protons of Val(4) and Leu(10), whereas His(16) seems similarly affected as before. Conversely, STD effects on Tyr(8) are strongly diminished, and those on Lys(18) and/or Lys(19) are abolished. Additionally, Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy of KcsA in presence of (13)C-labeled peptide derivatives suggests that the ShB peptide, but not the ShB-L7E mutant, adopts a beta-hairpin structure when bound to the KcsA channel. Indeed, docking such a beta-hairpin structure into an open pore model for K(+) channels to simulate the inactivating peptide/channel complex predicts interactions well in agreement with the experimental observations.

Protein self-assembly and lipid binding in the folding of the potassium channel KcsA.

Moderate concentrations of the alcohol 2,2,2-trifluoroethanol (TFE) cause the coupled unfolding and dissociation into subunits of the homotetrameric potassium channel KcsA, in a process that is partially irreversible when the protein is solubilized in plain dodecyl beta-d-maltoside (DDM) micelles [Barrera et al. (2005) Biochemistry 44, 14344-52]. Here we report that the transition from the folded tetramer to the unfolded monomer becomes completely reversible when KcsA is solubilized in mixed micelles composed of the detergent DDM and the lipids DOPE (1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoethanolamine) and DOPG (1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-[phospho-rac-(1-glycerol)]). This result suggests that lipids may act as effectors in the tetramerization of KcsA. The observed reversibility allowed the determination of the standard free energy of the folding reaction of KcsA: DeltaG = 30.5 +/- 3.1 kcal x mol-1. We also observed that, prior to the unfolding of the tetramer, the presence of lower TFE concentrations causes the disassembly of supramolecular clusters of KcsA into the individual tetrameric molecules. Within the limits of experimental resolution, this is also a reversible process, but unlike the tetramer to monomer transition from above, the level of clustering is not influenced by the presence of solubilized lipids. These observations suggest a distinct role of the lipids in the different in vitro assembly steps (folding/tetramerization and clustering) of KcsA.

Dynamics of tryptophan in the histidine-containing phosphocarrier protein of Streptomyces coelicolor: evidence of multistate equilibrium unfolding.

The nanosecond dynamics of the single tryptophan, Trp10, of HPr from Streptomyces coelicolor, HPrsc, has been monitored at different pHs. Time-resolved fluorescence methods and DOSY measurements have been used to map the compactness of the protein. At low pHs, where a molten globule-like species has been described, the correlation times from fluorescence showed an abrupt change as the pH was increased. When the protein was folded (above pH 4), two correlation times were observed, which remained practically constant up to pH 9.5. The long correlation time, around 7.5 ns, corresponds to the global rotational motion of the protein, since this value is in agreement with that determined theoretically from hydrodynamic measurements. The short correlation time, around 1.4 ns, must report on fast movements of the protein segment containing the tryptophan residue. On the other hand, fluorescence lifetimes showed the same abrupt change as the correlation times at low pH, but, in addition, a sigmoidal change with a pKa approximately 4.3 was also observed. On the basis of the modeled structure of HPrsc, this last transition could be due to the proximity of Glu12 to Trp10. The changes monitored by the fluorescence lifetimes agree with those observed previously by steady-state fluorescence, CD, and ANS binding experiments. Taken together, these data suggest a multistate equilibrium during folding of HPrsc starting from low pHs.

Effects of conducting and blocking ions on the structure and stability of the potassium channel KcsA.

This article reports on the interaction of conducting (K(+)) and blocking (Na(+)) monovalent metal ions with detergent-solubilized and lipid-reconstituted forms of the K(+) channel KcsA. Monitoring of the protein intrinsic fluorescence reveals that the two ions bind competitively to KcsA with distinct affinities (dissociation constants for the KcsA.K(+) and KcsA.Na(+) complexes of approximately 8 and 190 mm, respectively) and induce different conformations of the ion-bound protein. The differences in binding affinity as well as the higher K(+) concentration bathing the intracellular mouth of the channel, through which the cations gain access to the protein binding sites, should favor that only KcsA.K(+) complexes are formed under physiological-like conditions. Nevertheless, despite such prediction, it was also found that concentrations of Na(+) well below its dissociation constant and even in the presence of higher K(+) concentrations, cause a remarkable decrease in the protein thermal stability and facilitate thermal dissociation into subunits of the tetrameric KcsA, as concluded from the temperature dependence of the protein infrared spectra and from gel electrophoresis, respectively. These latter observations cannot be explained based on the occupancy of the binding sites from above and suggest that there must be additional ion binding sites, whose occupancy could not be detected by fluorescence and in which the affinity for Na(+) must be higher or at least similar to that of K(+). Moreover, cation binding as reported by means of fluorescence does not suffice to explain the large differences in free energy of stabilization involved in the formation of the KcsA.Na(+) and KcsA.K(+) complexes, which for the most part should arise from synergistic effects of the ion-mediated intersubunit interactions.

Clustering and coupled gating modulate the activity in KcsA, a potassium channel model.

Different patterns of channel activity have been detected by patch clamping excised membrane patches from reconstituted giant liposomes containing purified KcsA, a potassium channel from prokaryotes. The more frequent pattern has a characteristic low channel opening probability and exhibits many other features reported for KcsA reconstituted into planar lipid bilayers, including a moderate voltage dependence, blockade by Na(+), and a strict dependence on acidic pH for channel opening. The predominant gating event in this low channel opening probability pattern corresponds to the positive coupling of two KcsA channels. However, other activity patterns have been detected as well, which are characterized by a high channel opening probability (HOP patterns), positive coupling of mostly five concerted channels, and profound changes in other KcsA features, including a different voltage dependence, channel opening at neutral pH, and lack of Na(+) blockade. The above functional diversity occurs correlatively to the heterogeneous supramolecular assembly of KcsA into clusters. Clustering of KcsA depends on protein concentration and occurs both in detergent solution and more markedly in reconstituted membranes, including giant liposomes, where some of the clusters are large enough (up to micrometer size) to be observed by confocal microscopy. As in the allosteric conformational spread responses observed in receptor clustering (Bray, D. and Duke, T. (2004) Annu. Rev. Biophys. Biomol. Struct. 33, 53-73) our tenet is that physical clustering of KcsA channels is behind the observed multiple coupled gating and diverse functional responses.

Non-uniform membrane probe distribution in resonance energy transfer: application to protein-lipid selectivity.

Biological membranes are, at the molecular level, quasi-two dimensional systems. Membrane components are often distributed non-uniformly in the bilayer plane, as a consequence of lipid phase separation/domain formation or local enrichment/depletion of particular lipid species arising form favorable/unfavorable lipid-membrane protein interactions. Due to its explicit dependence on donor-acceptor distance or local acceptor concentration, resonance energy transfer (RET) has large potential in the characterization of membrane heterogeneity. RET formalisms for the basic geometric arrangements relevant for membranes have now been known for several decades. However, these formalisms usually assume uniform distributions, and more general models are required for the study of membrane lateral heterogeneity. We present a model that addresses the possibility of non-uniform acceptor (e.g., lipid probe) distribution around each donor (e.g., protein) in a membrane. It considers three regions with distinct local acceptor concentration, namely, an exclusion zone, the membrane bulk, and, lying in between, a region of enhanced probability of finding acceptors (annular region). Numerical solutions are presented, and convenient empirical fitting functions are given for RET efficiency as a function of bulk acceptor surface concentration, for several values of the model parameters. The usefulness of the formalism is illustrated in the analysis of experimental data.

Unfolding and refolding in vitro of a tetrameric, alpha-helical membrane protein: the prokaryotic potassium channel KcsA.

2,2,2-Trifluoroethanol (TFE) effectively destabilizes the otherwise highly stable tetrameric structure of the potassium channel KcsA, a predominantly alpha-helical membrane protein [Valiyaveetil, F. I., Zhou, Y., and MacKinnon, R. (2002) Biochemistry 41, 10771-10777]. Here, we report that the effects on the protein structure of increasing concentrations of TFE in detergent solution include two successive protein concentration-dependent, cooperative transitions. In the first of such transitions, occurring at lower TFE concentrations, the tetrameric KcsA simultaneously increases the exposure of tryptophan residues to the solvent, partly loses its secondary structure, and dissociates into its constituent subunits. Under these conditions, simple dilution of the TFE permits a highly efficient refolding and tetramerization of the protein in the detergent solution. Moreover, following reconstitution into asolectin giant liposomes, the refolded protein exhibits nativelike potassium channel activity, as assessed by patch-clamp methods. Conversely, the second cooperative transition occurring at higher TFE concentrations results in the irreversible denaturation of the protein. These results are interpreted in terms of a protein and TFE concentration-dependent reversible equilibrium between the folded tetrameric protein and partly unfolded monomeric subunits, in which folding and oligomerization (or unfolding and dissociation in the other direction of the equilibrium process) are seemingly coupled processes. At higher TFE concentrations this is followed by the irreversible conversion of the unfolded monomers into a denatured protein form.

Binding of the C-terminal sterile alpha motif (SAM) domain of human p73 to lipid membranes.

The alpha splice variant of p73 (p73alpha), a homologue of the tumor suppressor p53, has close to its C terminus a sterile alpha motif (SAM), SAMp73, that is thought to be involved in protein-protein interactions. Here, we report the lipid binding properties of this domain. Binding was assayed against zwitterionic (phosphatidylcholine) and anionic (phosphatidic acid) lipids and was studied by different biophysical techniques, namely, circular dichroism and fluorescence spectroscopies and differential scanning calorimetry. These techniques unambiguously indicate that SAMp73 binds to lipids. The binding involves protein surface attachment and partial membrane penetration, accompanied by changes in SAMp73 structure.

Intrinsic tyrosine fluorescence as a tool to study the interaction of the shaker B "ball" peptide with anionic membranes.

Steady-state and time-resolved fluorescence from the single tyrosine in the inactivating peptide of the Shaker B potassium channel (ShB peptide) and in a noninactivating peptide mutant, ShB-L7E, has been used to characterize their interaction with anionic phospholipid membranes, a model target mimicking features of the inactivation site on the channel protein. Partition coefficients derived from steady-state anisotropy indicate that both peptides show a high affinity for anionic vesicles, being higher in ShB than in ShB-L7E. Moreover, differential quenching by lipophilic spin-labeled probes and fluorescence energy transfer using trans-parinaric acid as the acceptor confirm that the ShB peptide inserts deep into the membrane, while the ShB-L7E peptide remains near the membrane surface. The rotational mobility of tyrosine in membrane-embedded ShB, examined from the decay of fluorescence anisotropy, can be described by two different rotational correlation times and a residual constant value. The short correlation time corresponds to fast rotation reporting on local tyrosine mobility. The long rotational correlation time and the high residual anisotropy suggest that the ShB peptide diffuses in a viscous and anisotropic medium compatible with the aliphatic region of a lipid bilayer and support the hypothesis that the peptide inserts into it as a monomer, to configure an intramolecular beta-hairpin structure. Assuming that this hairpin structure behaves like a rigid body, we have estimated its dimensions and rotational dynamics, and a model for the peptide inserted into the bilayer has been proposed.

Segregation of phosphatidic acid-rich domains in reconstituted acetylcholine receptor membranes.

Purified Acetylcholine Receptor (AcChR) from Torpedo has been reconstituted at low (approximately 1:3500) and high (approximately 1:560) protein to phospholipid molar ratios into vesicles containing egg phosphatidylcholine, cholesterol, and different dimyristoyl phospholipids (dimyristoyl phosphatidylcholine, phosphatidylserine, phosphatidylglycerol and phosphatidic acid) as probes to explore the effects of the protein on phospholipid organization by differential scanning calorimetry, infrared, and fluorescence spectroscopy. All the experimental results indicate that the presence of the AcChR protein, even at the lower protein to phospholipid molar ratio, directs lateral phase separation of the monoanionic phosphoryl form of the phosphatidic acid probe, causing the formation of specific phosphatidic acid-rich lipid domains that become segregated from the bulk lipids and whose extent (phosphatidic acid sequestered into the domain, out of the total population in the vesicle) is protein-dependent. Furthermore, fluorescence energy transfer using the protein tryptophan residues as energy donors and the fluorescence probes trans-parinaric acid or diphenylhexatriene as acceptors, establishes that the AcChR is included in the domain. Other dimyristoyl phospholipid probes (phosphatidylcholine, phosphatidylserine, phosphatidylglycerol) under identical conditions could not mimic the protein-induced domain formation observed with the phosphatidic acid probe and result in ideal mixing of all lipid components in the reconstituted vesicles. Likewise, in the absence of protein, all the phospholipid probes, including phosphatidic acid, exhibit ideal mixing behavior. Since phosphatidic acid and cholesterol have been implicated in functional modulation of the reconstituted AcChR, it is suggested that such a specific modulatory role could be mediated by domain segregation of the relevant lipid classes.